More Than A Piece of Crap

“She’s just a useless piece of crap!” These words have echoed in my headspace. No matter how I tried to shake them off, they stuck to my psyche like a sticky price tag. They determined my worth. Though the words peeled off, the sticky residue refused to unstick.

For more than twenty years, I tried to prove these words wrong. But anytime I made a mistake, forgot something, disappointed myself or anyone else, even when I noticed other people contributing more than me, the words shouted loud.

What gives destructive words inside a person’s head so much power? I believe comparisons give negative words power. We believe the destructive words because we compare our weaknesses with the strengths of those around us, and we fail to measure up to an impossible standard.

Secondly, destructive words increase power when we give them a podium in our headspace. Emily Freeman tells the story of an Uber driver she met while travelling. The driver tells of a customer who was impossible to please. But rather than repeat what the unkind customer had said, the Uber driver says to Emily, “I’m not going to give her words.” Contrary to the wisdom of this driver, we often repeat the destructive words, allowing them to shout loud in our headspace. Repetition increases the power of words.

According to Beth Moore, in her Bible Study “Believing God,” human words have power because we’re created in God’s image. If God’s words have power to create the intricate design of the human ear, and if we are created in God’s image, then our words have power as well. If God’s word is omnipotent, it stands to reason that our words are potent – to re-create and to destroy. So, both our destructive and encouraging words are powerful, just because we are created in the image of the all powerful God.

Although words can kill, words can also give life. Encouraging words have power to heal the crushed spirit. For years, I fought the “useless crap” label by wielding words of truth. Call it Cognitive Behavioural Therapy or “taking captive every thought to make it obedient to Christ” (2 Cor 10:5). And I found these disciplines helpful. The voice in my head grew kinder.

In fact, after years of listening to God’s words, that I’m his treasure, that I’m chosen, woven, sculpted, I thought the last of the nasty adhesive was finally gone. But just a few weeks ago, when I found myself facing certain failure – or so it seemed – the “Useless Crap” words screamed at me again. Will I ever be free of this nasty label?

Then I attended a listening prayer group and to my astonishment, someone shared an image of a “pile of crap”. We think it’s useless… but in reality, manure is nature’s fertilizer. It nourishes soil and transforms seeds, small dead things, into roses, radishes and even redwoods.

I got to thinking how we mix manure into soil. And soil is dirt and dirt is dust. And dust is what God used to create man. “The LORD God formed a man from the dust of the ground and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life” (Genesis 2: 7 NIV).

According to Lois Tverberg in Reading the Bible with Rabbi Jesus, this statement is more than a sensory description of the creation of man. A Jewish reader schooled in Jewish history and literature would understand that in the Bible, “dust” is a symbol of “insignificance or finiteness.” Therefore, this description where God breathes life into the man shaped dust, is a paradoxical statement about “our unique value… that we draw our lives from God Himself but are formed from nothing but dirt.”

Is this the reason we wrestle with our self worth? I’ve heard it said that this struggle is woven into the female psyche. However, I believe it is universal rather than feminine in nature. Men and women, boys and girls, struggle to believe and prove they have value.

God could have formed humans from gold dust or diamonds, but instead he chose dirt. Right at creation he chose the substance of less value to form his image bearer. But he glorified the dust by breathing his own life into it, making humanity a little lower than the angels. So if God adds such value to dust, why not dung? God purposed manure to grow life – exquisite, nutritious and majestic. Isn’t it like God to waste nothing? Even waste is useful for growing “beautiful things out of dust.”

And so the “crap” label loses the last of it’s sting. But, can God do anything with the word “useless”? Henri Nouwen tells the story of “The Useless Tree,”

A carpenter and his apprentice were walking together through a large forest. And when they came across a tall, huge, gnarled, old, beautiful tree, the carpenter asked his apprentice: “Do you know why this tree is so tall, so huge, so gnarled, so old and beautiful?” The apprentice looked at his master and said: “No…why?”

“Well” the carpenter said, “because it is useless. If it had been useful it would have been cut long ago and made into tables and chairs, but because it is useless it could grow so tall and so beautiful that you can sit in its shade and relax.”

The “useless” tree has purpose, just not in the form of profit. Because it’s purpose is not readily accessible, the tree trades usefulness for time to develop and grow. The tree is overlooked and so, rather than offering rest to one family in the form of table and chairs, it offers rest to the whole community in the form of shade and cathedral.

This label, “ Useless Piece of Crap” has come to mean someone rare and precious, who nurtures, nourishes, and causes seeds to flourish. So perhaps words that were meant to harm, God meant for good. These cursing words have been reversed into blessing and perhaps even calling.

Can God really turn cursing words into blessing? This is no less a miracle than turning water into wine. Who is this, that even wind and words obey him?

Reading

Genesis 37:12-28, 45:1-7, 50:20; 2 Corinthians 10:4-5;

Philippians 4:4-8; Matthew 8:23-27

Pondering

Do you wear any labels that need removing or better yet, redeeming? What are the words in your headspace that don’t deserve the podium? What is the truth that counters these words in your head? Is there blessing hidden deep within the words you carry? Ask the Holy Spirit to reverse any curses you carry into blessing. Ask for a fresh perspective to hear God’s interpretation of the words in your head.

Works Cited

Moore, Beth. Believing God. B & H Publishing Group, 2015, p116-119.

Spiritual Formation: Following the Movements of the Spirit, by Henri J. M. Nouwen et al., HarperOne, an Imprint of HarperCollins Publishers, 2015, Moore, Beth. Believing God. B & H Publishing Group, 2015, p17.

Tverberg, Lois. Reading the Bible with Rabbi Jesus: How a Jewish Perspective Can Transform Your Understanding. Baker Books, 2018, ch 5, Greek Brain, Hebrew Brain

HEADER PHOTO by marcus-wallis-unsplash
Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

Recent Posts:

The Halloween Fairy

My child’s face mirrored mine. I looked into my heavenly Dad’s face and saw his eyes shining delight. He dried my tears and held my aching heart.

Read More »

Anguished Thanks

Thanksgiving. Really? How? How can the seasons continue when your heart is ripped with grief? How does your heart keep beating when sorrow steals your

Read More »

Listen to the Sky

Did you listen to the sky on January 20, 2019?  In North America we were blessed with a full lunar eclipse.  And here on the

Read More »

Longing to Behold

I must confess, I have a love/hate relationship with Christmas. I love the lights. What better way is there to light up the darkest time

Read More »

18 thoughts on “More Than A Piece of Crap”

  1. Oh my dear sweet Katherine. I wept thru most of these. I love you my friend and am so thankful to be apart of your life. Your writing is beautiful, and more then that your heart connects with ours.

    1. Thank you for your kind words,Kim. And thank you for modeling courage to dig deeply into your own pain. We have been blessed to be part of a community of brave women and men who have sifted through the dust of pain and found gold. Your story of pain and healing and repeat, has been a catalyst for my journey that has brought me to this place. I pray that many people will find healing, freedom and joy in this “grace to embrace” community. You are beautiful, Kim!

  2. Oh my! I never allowed my children to say “Holy Cr-p” because only God is holy. Now I have a whole new perspective…God uses everything to show His glory.
    “God purposed manure to grow life – exquisite, nutritious and majestic. Isn’t it like God to waste nothing? Even waste is useful for growing “beautiful things out of dust.” Now when my adult children use the wrong word paired with Holy, I will hear it with less of a sting. Thank you for changing my perspective.

    1. Hmm, an interesting perspective. I hear you, I don’t like the way language is used flippantly, crude phrases that were once considered offensive, forbidden in the classroom, now used in mainstream media and crossing the lips of Christ followers. We believe or “feel” that our thoughts shape our words, but George Orwell argues that our words also shape our thinking. I believe that our words matter and I’m delighted that the redemption of this word that damaged my thinking has helped to reduce it’s sting for you. You’ve raised another aspect to the power of words which I didn’t directly address, but is worthy of discussion in my view. If you’re interested in reading George Orwell’s essay, it’s called “Politics and the English Language.

    1. Thanks Joanne. That is my goal, to “tell what the Lord has done.” And everything he does is motivated by love.

  3. Karen Zimmermann

    Hi Katherine. So excited your blog is up and running now. Great devotional for me! I look forward to all your future posts. You have such insight and knowledge and a way with words that I pray will reach many more people who need to read this!!
    I love thinking that we were made from the most useless substance on this earth and God has made us the most valued beings on this earth.
    Breathe oh breath of God.
    Amen.
    Thank you 😊

    1. Thanks Karen. I’m delighted if you can use this as a devotional tool. I know I often need more than a day to dig into the Bible words that speak to me, so I’m hoping that between the Bible references, the questions for pondering, and my story, there’s some material here to chew on for several days. Enjoy!

  4. Thanks for the gift of your words, Katherine. I love the way you have woven “crap, dirt and dust” together … something made holy by the breath and attention of our magnificent and holy God. Well said. And congratulations on your blog! Keep on sharing.

  5. Ahhhh, good words for all of us to heed! I too had an experience from last March that had a hold in my psyche. Until God finally got through to me that they were the lies of the enemy. What a waste of time for me in believing the lies.

    1. So grateful that God graciously lifts our heads, and untangles the lies. Keep walking in truth, head high, my friend.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.